You have been offered a settlement. After months of stress, the number on the page may feel like relief. Then comes a question many people only ask after they sign: how much of this will I actually keep?
The answer depends on how the settlement is structured, what the payments are for, and how the agreement is written. Employment settlements are generally taxable, but not all payments are taxed the same way, and the language in the agreement can change your tax bill. This guide explains the basics so you can ask better questions before you agree to anything.
This article is general information, not tax advice. Tax rules are complex and change, and you should consult a qualified tax professional about your own situation.
The General Rule: Most of It Is Taxable
Under federal tax law, money you receive to settle an employment claim is usually treated as income unless a specific exclusion applies. Settlements of discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination claims are typically taxable, with limited exceptions.
What changes is how the different parts are taxed.
Wages: Back Pay and Front Pay
Payments that replace lost wages, such as back pay and front pay, are treated as wages. That means:
- The employer must withhold income tax and the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare taxes
- You receive a Form W-2
- The employer also pays its own share of payroll taxes
If your settlement is $60,000 and $30,000 is allocated to back pay, expect the employer to withhold from that portion before you see it, the same way a paycheck is reduced. Severance pay is also generally treated as wages.
Emotional Distress and Other Non-Wage Damages
Payments for emotional distress, pain and suffering, reputational harm, and punitive damages are generally taxable income, but they are usually not subject to payroll tax withholding. The employer typically reports them on a Form 1099 instead of a W-2. You are responsible for reporting the income and paying the tax, often with no withholding up front, so plan for it.
There is an important exception. Damages received on account of physical injury or physical sickness can be excluded from income under the federal tax code, but emotional distress on its own generally does not qualify as a physical injury. Medical expenses you paid to treat emotional distress may be treated differently, if you did not previously deduct them. These distinctions are technical, and the facts matter.
Attorney’s Fees: The Surprise
Many people assume that if they pay a third of their settlement to a lawyer, they only owe tax on what they keep. That is not how it generally works. Under long-standing federal tax rules, the portion paid to your attorney can be treated as income to you, even if it goes directly to the lawyer.
Congress addressed part of this problem in 2004. Section 62(a)(20) of the Internal Revenue Code allows an above-the-line deduction for attorney’s fees and court costs paid in connection with claims of unlawful discrimination, and certain other claims covered by the statute. That deduction effectively cancels out the tax on the fee portion for qualifying claims, with some limits. For example, the deduction generally cannot exceed the amount of taxable income from the settlement for that year.
Not every claim qualifies. A breach of contract claim, for example, may be treated differently from a discrimination claim. Whether your claim qualifies depends on its nature.
New Jersey’s state tax treatment may differ from the federal treatment. We understand that New Jersey does not offer an equivalent of the federal above-the-line deduction, which can mean state tax on the fee portion. Because this is a technical area, confirm with a tax professional.
Why the Settlement Agreement’s Wording Matters
Tax authorities and courts often look at what a settlement payment was meant to compensate, and the settlement agreement is usually the best evidence. A well-drafted agreement:
- Separates payments into categories, such as back pay (W-2), emotional distress (1099), and attorney’s fees (1099 to the attorney, and sometimes to you)
- Identifies who issues which forms
- Describes the claims being released accurately
A vague agreement can lead to disputes, or to the employer treating the entire payment as wages. Allocation is also negotiable. The employer generally prefers to put more in categories that are not subject to payroll tax, and the way the numbers are split affects both sides.
The Lump-Sum Problem
A large settlement paid in one year can push you into a higher tax bracket. Depending on the facts, options may exist to smooth the impact, such as negotiating payment in installments or timing the payment across tax years. Some settlements address back pay that would have been earned over several years, and the tax effect can be harsh. In some cases, courts have adjusted awards to address adverse tax consequences, but that is a matter for your lawyer and tax adviser.
Other Items to Raise Before You Sign
- Interest. Interest on a judgment or settlement is generally taxable.
- Benefits and retirement contributions. Ask whether any part of the payment is intended to cover lost employer contributions to retirement or health plans, and how it will be treated.
- Unemployment and other benefits. Settlement payments can interact with benefits you received. Ask a lawyer how that applies.
- Reporting forms. If you receive a W-2 and a 1099 for the same settlement, confirm they match the agreement before you file.
- Confidentiality and non-disparagement. These terms do not change the tax result, but they are central to your decision about the settlement overall.
- Medicare and liens. If you receive government benefits, there may be reporting or reimbursement issues.
Questions to Ask Before You Agree
- How is the payment divided among wages, non-wage damages, and attorney’s fees?
- Which forms will I receive, and when?
- What will be withheld, and what will I owe on my own?
- How is my attorney’s fee treated, federally and in New Jersey?
- Can any part of the payment be spread over more than one tax year?
- Does the agreement describe the claims accurately?
For how fees and costs work from the start, see how much an employment lawyer costs in New Jersey. For how claims are valued, read how much a New Jersey employment case may be worth. If your settlement involves a separation agreement, our post on negotiating a severance package covers terms to look for. You can find general tax information at irs.gov.
Talk to a New Jersey Employment Lawyer
A lawyer cannot replace a tax professional, but a good one will raise these issues during the negotiation, when you still have leverage. Contact Charles Z. Schalk or call (908) 526-0707 for a free, confidential consultation. See our wrongful discharge page for the types of claims we handle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are employment settlements taxable?
Generally, yes. Most settlements of discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination claims are taxable income. Different parts are taxed differently: back pay is wages, while emotional distress damages are usually reported on a Form 1099.
Is a wrongful termination settlement taxable in New Jersey?
Usually, yes, federally. State treatment can differ, so check with a tax professional about New Jersey. Back pay is generally treated as wages and subject to withholding.
Are emotional distress damages taxable?
Typically yes, unless they stem from a physical injury or physical sickness. Emotional distress damages are usually reported on a 1099 without withholding, so set aside money for the tax bill.
Do I have to pay tax on the money that goes to my lawyer?
Often the fee portion is treated as your income, but for discrimination and certain other claims, federal law allows an above-the-line deduction for attorney’s fees and costs. The deduction has limits, and New Jersey’s treatment may differ.
Is severance pay taxable?
Yes. Severance is generally treated as wages and is subject to income and payroll tax withholding.
Can the settlement agreement affect how much tax I pay?
Yes. How payments are allocated and described in the agreement often influences how they are reported. Review the wording with your lawyer and tax adviser before you sign.
This article is provided for general informational purposes and is not legal or tax advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Tax rules are complex and change, and every situation is different. Consult a qualified tax professional. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.